Freeholders Approve $7.5 Million Payment To Florida-Based Ashbritt For Storm Debris Removal

Board members deny Ocean County GOP chief George R. Gilmore had anything to do with securing Ashbritt

Ocean County officials had two ways to go after Superstorm Sandy - wait three months for the complex bid process for debris removal, or go with Florida-based Ashbritt and start immediately, Freeholder Director John P. Kelly said today.

"We had two choices in Ocean County," Kelly said at the Board of Freeholders meeting Wednesday in Toms River. "It was the only action that made sense."

Nearly all of the discussion at the meeting centered on the use of Ashbritt for debris removal, the aftermath of Superstorm Sandy and Ocean County's eventual recovery.

Ocean County signed on with AshBritt in mid-November, and offered a shared services agreement to county municipalities for Sandy-related debris removal.

Under the shared services agreement, towns that signed on with the county used AshBritt for debris removal, with the county footing the bill upfront and seeking reimbursement from the Federal Emergency Management Administration.

Municipalities could opt in to a shared service agreement with the county for debris removal, or handle the debris removal on their own. Eventually, 19 towns signed up for the shared services.

"Every town was in here, clamoring," Kelly said. "We didn't force anybody to do this."

Towns that participated in the agreement will have to reimburse the county for the amount not covered by FEMA, which could be as little as 10 percent or as much as 25 percent of the cost, depending on final disaster figure determinations.

Reports that the contract was a no-bid deal are inaccurate, Freeholder John C. Bartlett Jr. has said.

"The contract (with AshBritt) was originally bid in Connecticut," Bartlett said in January. "New Jersey was able to make use of that bid to hire AshBritt," and the county was then able to piggyback on the state as a result.

The county was able to pay the bills upfront because of Ocean County's AAA bond rating and surplus. Ocean County will be reimbursed by FEMA for much of the cost, Bartlett said.

"We have not had to borrow a dime for this," said Bartlett, who is liaison to the county finance department.

Kelly and Bartlett also clashed with a Star-Ledger reporter who got up during the public portion of the meeting to ask questions.

When Jarrett Renshaw - who wrote several stories questioning Ashbritt receiving contracts in New Jersey - asked if the board had considered going out to bid for the work, Bartlett exploded.

"I can't think of anything more stupid in the whole world," Bartlett said.

If the county had gone out to bid on the work, it would have taken months before any debris could have been removed because of the bid process, he said

"We should all sit around here chewing our thumbs?" Bartlett said. "That's dumb. We are here to get a job done."

Renshaw also questioned whether Ocean County GOP chief George R. Gilmore had anything to do with securing Ashbritt's services. Gilmore told the Star-Ledger he was a consultant for the firm, but declined to detail his responsibilities.

"It would be three months to wait for the competitive bid process," Kelly said. "We were never hit with a storm of this magnitude in the history of this county. Maybe your newspaper doesn't like it. I could care less who George Gilmore works for. I didn't even know about it until I read it in the newspaper."

Bartlett angrily denied that Gilmore had spoken to anyone on the freeholder board about using Ashbritt.

"George Gilmore had absolutely no relation to the Board of Chosen Freeholders' involvement with the Ashbritt contract whatsover," Bartlett said. "I can assure you there was no contact with Mr. Gilmore. The five members of this board, we run the county and any other insinuation is a lie."

Patch contacted Gilmore yesterday for comment. Gilmore said he wanted to discuss his role with Ashbritt, but had signed a confidentiality agreement. He told Patch he would discuss the matter later in the day. He did not return four subsequent phone calls.

Bartlett also explained the complex process that led to the board's approval of the $7.5 million payment to Ashbritt - the third payment made to the firm since Sandy slammed into the Jersey Shore on Oct. 29.

"It's not as if someone sends us a bill and we pay," Bartlett said.

The contract with Ashbritt called for the removal of all debris on streets and rights-of-way, Bartlett said.

Every truck that picked up debris had an independent monitor on board to oversee the pickup and amount of debris picked up on an individual run. The debris was then taken to local transfer stations, where a monitor signed off on the total cubic yardage. The debris was separated by category - cement, asphalt and brick; wood and garbage; and white goods like refrigerators and metals, Bartlett said.

Anything that could be recycled was. Wood and garbage was trucked to the Ocean County Landfill in Manchester Township, where the tipping fees are $81.21 a ton, Bartlett said.

"Anyone who says they can remove this for less then that, doesn't know what they are talking about," he said.

The county's chief financial officer compared the voucher costs with the unit prices in the contract, Bartlett said.

"Once they all line up with the monitor's certification, the CFO signs a voucher forwards it to the Board of Freeholders," Bartlett said. "That is the process. It's all done under a state contract, all according to a monitor's verification. I don't know what else can be done or said."

Freeholder Gerry P. Little was the board's director when Sandy hit on Oct. 29, Kelly said.

"He made sure this Board of Freeholders knew everything that was going on," Kelly said. "I'm proud of the actions this county took. We helped not only municipalities, but homeowners, so they could start to put their lives back together."

"To remove that debris was vital," Freeholder Joseph H. Vicari said. "We have tried our best to do the right thing. They did an outstanding job under tremendous pressure. Our job is to do whatever is in our power to get to a new normalcy."

Jackthebear February 07, 2013 at 02:22 AM
Maybe Gilmore is a historian for Ashbritt.
TR Grouch February 07, 2013 at 02:27 AM
Its a shame then that Ashbrit wasted its money hiring George Gilmore as their agent to push their services since George never even went to the Freeholders on this. I sure hope they didn't pay him the six figured salary its rumored he was paid for his services.
10% Tax Cut NOW February 07, 2013 at 02:31 AM
Ashbritt isn't the only State Contract vendor for this service, why wasn't another company(s) picked ?
TR Grouch February 07, 2013 at 02:32 AM
George is the most powerful Republican in Ocean County. Why would Ashbrit put him on the payroll? Duhhh
Michael Grimes February 07, 2013 at 03:13 AM
Patricia, are pickups still being done in Toms River?
Chief Wahoo February 07, 2013 at 04:16 AM
The good old boys seem to be losing control.
john February 07, 2013 at 11:14 AM
complain about the no bid aspect or complain about the debris stacked sky hi for months after the storm. glad the area s are cleaned up, imo the county acted in good faith ...have to remember the shore area means billions of dollars of revenue for new jersey overall..... it had to get cleaned up and fast.....
Robert Bressman February 07, 2013 at 12:53 PM
I think the Freeholders are taking the same tact as the Governor, get nasty and that will stop the questions. For Kelly to say that Ash-Britt was actually a bid contract, when in fact it was a bid contract from 2008 from another state is shear arrogance and disrespect to the person asking the question. To further suggest that Gilmore didn't use his influence, whether indirectly or directly is another insult to the people asking the questions. There were 4 bids put out for future disasters Ash-Britt had the highest bid, what does that ell you. The offer for the county to foot the bill for the municipalities was a guarantee that the towns would go with Ash-Britt. I hope that the Nj legislature turns over every rock to find out what really went between Ash- Britt and the people in charge that were supposed to protect the taxpayers. Kelly's claim we had to get it done right away, well, here we are 3 months later there is still garbage in the streets and for the most part few people are back in their homes, so what was the hurry?
Slippery Slope February 07, 2013 at 12:59 PM
You can only read comments if you are signed in. I dont know when or why this started but it has. I signed out and couldnt view any comments. I signed back in and there they were.
Martin February 07, 2013 at 01:18 PM
AshBritt's overinflated price per ton will come back to haunt county taxpayers. Big property tax bills will be mailed out this summer. County blames Christie (AshBritt's pal) for contracting with the co. at the Connecticut rate, and the county simply piggybacked on that contract. FEMA won't cover it all, leaving the rest to us little people to pay. We'll cover Gilmore's share, too. The whole deal really was "garbage."
mayorschroeder@ptboro.com February 07, 2013 at 01:26 PM
it's interesting that Point Pleasant has only received $48,000 and we cleaned up our own town...
Chief Wahoo February 07, 2013 at 01:31 PM
This corruption and cronyism is enough to make a person get so mad that they get a job in the tax office and keep all the cash payments for themselves. I will admit its does not make someone mad enough to go out and run someone over on a motorcycle however.
Xavier February 07, 2013 at 02:38 PM
I was signed in, could see the total number of comments but couldn't view them. When I came back later they had finally appeared. Maybe a glitch.
Dan February 07, 2013 at 03:25 PM
STATE OF NEW JERSEY LOCAL FINANCE BOARD NOTICE OF VIOLATION In Re: [Michael Fressola, Mayor, Township of Manchester, Complaint This matter having come before the Local Finance Board (Board) pursuant to the Local Government Ethics Law, N.J.S.A. et seq., upon complaint that Mayor Michael Fressola used the address and telephone number of the Township of Manchester City Hall in a political mail piece, using the resources of the Township for his personal gain and securing unwarranted privileges or advantages for himself and his campaign in violation of N.J.S.A. and, WHEREAS, the Board determined that the allegations were within its jurisdiction, were not frivolous and were based upon a reasonable factual basis, authorized an investigation of this complaint; and WHEREAS, the Local Government Ethics Law states: N.J.S.A. 40A: No local government officers or employee shall use or attempt to use his official position to secure unwarranted privileges or advantages for himself or others; and
Dan February 07, 2013 at 03:26 PM
WHEREAS, the Board, having considered the matter and the relevant statements and presented and all documentation with the written response to the allegations submitted by Mayor Fressola, concluded that the use of the Municipal Building address and telephone number in the letterhead of a political mailer distributed in connection with the May 11, 2010 election constitutes the use or attempted use of Mayor Fressola's official position to secure an unwarranted privilege or advantage for himself or others in violation of N.J.S.A. It is therefore, DETERMINED that Mayor Michael Fressola shall be assessed a fine in the amount of $100.00 for the violation as related to his engaging in activities prohibited by the statute. Said fine shall be payable to: Treasurer, State of New Jersey, and be submitted to: Thomas H. Neff, Chair, Local Finance Board, P.O. Box 803, Trenton, New Jersey, 08625 immediately. If payment of said fine is not received within 10 days receipt of this NOTICE, Mayor Fressola is subject to additional fines as determined by the Board in accordance with its powers in N.J.S.A.40A:9- 22.10, Violations and Penalties.
Sydney February 07, 2013 at 03:55 PM
Business as usual in the Soprano State.
jaime February 07, 2013 at 04:20 PM
well said and the question is WHY? maybe because ashbritt has friends and anyone who knows about the biding process knows it will take a while but in an emergency situation like sandy the town or county can give out the work so what they should have done was ask for several prices from other contractors like local contractors and see who came in the lowest!!! and ashbritt only got into town in the 3rd week of November so officials had plenty of time. we have some of the biggest contractors in NJ with a large work force at their finger tips waiting to go to work but no we give it to an out of state contractor. LOVE MY TAXES AT WORK
Exit82 February 07, 2013 at 06:13 PM
I can't help it. Gilmore, Ritacco, Block and the new guy Kelly in high school. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c2rphRaARPQ
1stcav February 07, 2013 at 09:26 PM
And yet NOTHING will happen in Boss Hog controlled territory, unless HE says it happens !!!! Even the Fed's back off @ Boss Hog !!!! Soooooo connected..WWJD ?LMAO in OC & NJ....Tony...How you doin ????? K ---how you doin ???


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something