A Puzzling Night in Berkeley Township
The Jan. 28 Township Council meeting at times seemed like a Berkeley Board of Education meeting
Township Councilwoman Fran Siddons had no idea of the backlash she would face when she suggested at a recent Berkeley Board of Education meeting that the district share more services with Central Regional.
That is, until she walked into the Township Council meeting room on Monday night and saw the left side filled with Berkeley bus drivers who were apparently afraid they would lose their jobs.
That is, until she saw several Berkeley Board of Education members - including board Vice-President Sophia Gingrich and board member Steven Pellecchia - sitting in the audience.
"I walked into a lynch mob," Siddons said Tuesday. "They took everything out of context. There was an agenda there last night and people in the audience knew it."
Siddons spoke at the recent Berkeley Board of Education meeting as a private citizen, although Board President James Fulcomer identified her as a council member on her way to the podium.
Here is what she said, in a nutshell, direct from the statement she read into the record.
Siddons urged the Berkeley school board to work out a plan with Central to reduce the number of department heads from eight to four.
She also suggested combining the transportation departments and having one superintendent and one business administrator to oversee both districts.
"These plans together should eventually save the taxpayers up to at least a million dollars a year," Siddons said in the statement. "This is an urgent need for our town, since people in our maritime areas have suffered great losses and the tax burden is likely to shift to the adult and other neighborhoods of our town. We can no longer afford the unnecessary expense of duplicate central administrations for our school districts."
That apparently was all it took for the anti-shared services faction to work the school bus drivers into a frenzy about the possible loss of their jobs.
Some drivers who spoke said the safety of the district's elementary school students would be compromised if the two districts' transportation departments were eventually merged.
Others - including Mayor Carmen F. Amato Jr. - were worried that kindergartners would be riding on the same buses as high school students.
"I would not be in favor of jeopardizing the safety of our students," Amato said.
Turns out none of that will happen. No bus drivers would lose their jobs. Little children would not be sharing seats with high school seniors.
Two years ago, Central Regional officials met with Berkeley district officials to explore the feasibility of merging the bus fleets for both districts, Central Regional Superintendent Triantafillos Parlapanides said today.
"It makes sense," he said. "We're only allowed to use buses for 15 years. Each of us has to buy three new buses a year. If you merge the fleet, one of us doesn't have to buy three buses a year. We would keep all the bus drivers. Nobody would lose their jobs."
Merging the two fleets would be a five to ten-year process. The only jobs eliminated would be through attrition, Parlapanides said.
There would be a three-tier bus run system if the fleets merged - high school students first; Central Regional Middle School and Berkeley Township Elementary School students, who are fifth and sixth-graders - next, and all other elementary school students shortly after. BTES and middle school students would not ride on the same buses, just have the same pick-up times, he said.
Together the two school districts have roughly 4,300 students. Neighboring Lacey Township, a K-12 district, has roughly 4,500. The Lacey school district has 38 school buses. Combined, Central Regional and Berkeley have 70 buses.
But just because the bus merging analysis makes sense, that doesn't mean it will happen. Past Berkeley school boards have never looked kindly at shared services. James Fulcomer - the current board president - was the lone vocal voice for shared services last year and was often lambasted for his views.
It took the school board more than two years to hire a permanent superintendent - after two interim superintendents. James D. Roselli was eventually hired, after the board hired a consultant for a superintendent search.
Parlapanides submitted his application and offered to take over the Berkeley school superintendent duties for free. He was never interviewed. Pellecchia, who was board president last year, said he didn't think Parlapanides was qualified.
Others in town may not agree with the school's board historical reluctance to shared services. Members of the Berkeley Township Taxpayers Coalition are beginning to attend board meetings.
Coalition member James Gallinaw said during the public portion of the council meeting that the group would be taking a close look at spending in the school districts this year.
"Schools happen to be higher here than other (tax) rates, so it's a likely source," he said. "We intend to do that and we will do it with the facts. We do support Fran Siddons. She spoke as a citizen, not as a councilwoman."
Current board member Salvatore Ferlise said at the council meeting that the board had not met recently with Central Regional officials to discuss any transportation issues.
But Ferlise did not rule out shared services for administrative positions, through attrition.
"If someone leaves their position...that would save us a lot of money," he said. "I don't know where this (bus drivers) got out, that people are going to be fired."
No one owned up to that at the council meeting. But it's clear there's a lot more going on behind the scenes. It should be an interesting year.
Chief Wahoo
12:10 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Merge these two overpaid baby sitting indoctrination statist boondoggles.
I am sick of all you public takers. This time is different. There is no money. Your false threats will no longer work.
Betsy Huhn
7:49 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Sounds like the Berkeley Board is playing their games again and trying to bully people to believe what they want them to believe. Merging makes sence.. And ALL the kids still need to be picked up and one fleet can not do it alone. So how could the drivers think they will loose their jobs.....Lets listen to the possibilities and then decide what is best!!!!
joeybayville
10:49 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
There should only be one Board in Berkeley. Amato should be worried about the entire township instead of a few friends on the Board. We all know taxes are going up with Amato in office. We need someone to make the right decisions about cost cutting measurements instead of playing games and making threats.
Jersey Girl for Life
9:25 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
This is in response to fears about high schoolers riding the bus with grade school kids. My children attended St. Joes grade school and rode a Central district bus with kids who attended Mon Don. (K-12 ride the same bus). The high schoolers weren't a problem but those in 5 6 7 were a little rough (in language and behavior). It was the older ones who watched out for the younger ones. Most juniors and seniors also drive to school rather than take the bus.
voice of reason
10:21 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Read the article omg
( There would be a three-tier bus run system if the fleets merged - high school students first; Central Regional Middle School and Berkeley Township Elementary School students, who are fifth and sixth-graders - next, and all other elementary school students shortly after. BTES and middle school students would not ride on the same buses, just have the same pick-up times, he said )
Bville
10:49 am on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
What is Fran Siddons doing? She easily could pick up phone and schedule to meet with Superintendent of both districts to voice her concerns and to find out the facts. Fran, if you want to be a private citizen, then resign from Council. You can't shed the office when it is convenient for you. When you go to any public meeting, you are representing the Town Council because of your office. Sorry but it is the truth. And Fran do not compare concerned tax paying bus drives to a "lynch mob" A horrible reference for a paid elected official to make.
voice of reason
12:56 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Are you telling me the bus drivers were there as concerned taxpayers ? Really comon they thought they might loose there job. wow you gotta be kiddin me READ THE ARTICLE they were there to bully and intimidate they dont care about taxes they ask for raises every year.
voice of reason
12:56 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
THIS SAYS IT ALL
Bville
12:57 pm on Thursday, September 6, 2012
I can't wait to keep the school board on. I am very happy with my child's education and thank you Dr. Roselli for quickly resolving the mold issue.
Lori
12:28 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
typical political scare tactics, and once again the little guy falls for it, time for this to happen and the only ones looking at a possible job loss are the ones at the top and lets face it most of those are political a$$ kisser jobs, so Im sure they will be placed somewhere else by their political offiliates
Bville
3:14 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Wow, bus drivers can't assemble at a town meeting. If they do, then they are there to bully and intimidate? Bus drivers are taxpayers too....income tax, property tax etc. so please don't tell me that they aren't. I bet most of them do live in town. I believe three tier bussing should be explored so I am not arguing that. My issue is with Councilwoman Siddons and her quote. Thank you Voice of Reason for posting my comments from September 6th. I stand behind it and unlike you, I am a supporter of the Berkeley Township School District.
Petra
3:14 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Ms. Siddons voiced her opinion at a Berkeley Township Board of Education meeting but doesn’t like it when her opinions are brought up again. She can’t have it both ways - as a public figure she opened herself up to this. Did she also go to a Central Board meeting and express those same views? Since Berkeley is the larger of the two Districts any shared services should be dictated by that District. Any change in administration should be done on the Central side as the smaller of the two entities.
voice of reason
6:01 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
If The larger district wanted shared services why did they not make any attempt at it? Thats the problem people like you who favour one or the other i favour the best people for the job
voice of reason
6:01 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Wow ok so the bus drivers went to the meeting as concerned tax payers READ THe ARTIClE its about merging buses and pissible bus drivers loosing there jobs i dont doubt they are taxpayers but dont tell me they went to that meeting as concerned taxpayers and fyi i support cutting taxes and useing tax $$$ for what they are intended to educate the kids not to employ people including bus drivers if they are not needed
Dawn Parks
6:00 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Here is the proposal for Berkeley Township Schools and Central Regional School District for Shared Service Agreement for Busing
Comparison:
Lacey Township Schools: Total Student Population k-12 4500 students
Buses: 38 buses
Berkeley Township Schools: Total Students Population K-6 2300 students
Central Regional School District 2000 students
Total: 4300
Berkeley Township Schools: 32 buses
Central Regional School District: 38 buses
Total: 70 Buses
INITIAL COST SAVING THE FIRST YEAR: 200,000 TO 400,000 FOR EACH DISTRICT
STEPS THAT NEED TO BE TAKEN:
1. HIRE BARBARA SARGEANT AS THE SHARED COORDINATOR. THIS WILL SAVE ON HEALTH BENEFITS AND SALARY FOR BERKELEY TOWNSHIP. CENTRAL WOULD BE PAID $50,000, WITH $30,000 GOING TOWARD THE SHARED COORDINATOR’S SALARY AND $20,000 GOING TO CENTRAL.
2. NO ONE WILL BE LET GO!! WE CAN USE ALL DRIVERS IN JOINTURES TO BRING MONEY INTO BOTH DISTRICTS!
3. IF A BERKELEY DRIVER IS DOING A JOINTURE THEN BERKELEY BOARD OF EDUCATION GETS THE MONEY. IF A CENTRAL DRIVER IS DOING A JOINTURE THEN THE CENTRAL REGIONAL BOARD OF EDUCATION GETS THE MONEY.
4. IT WOULD BE A 5 TO 10 YEAR PROCESS TO MERGE THE FLEETS. AS PEOPLE RETIRE, THEY WOULD NOT BE REPLACED.
Dawn Parks
5:59 pm on Wednesday, January 30, 2013
5. BUSES MUST BE REPLACED EVER 15 YEARS. THIS MEANS BOTH DISTRICTS ARE PURCHASING 3 NEW BUSES A YEAR TO MAINTAIN BOTH FLEETS. BY MERGING THE FLEETS, WE MIGHT NOT HAVE TO BY FOR A FEW YEARS OR ONLY PURCHASE 3 NEW BUSES A YEAR INSTEAD OF 6 BETWEEN THE DISTRICTS. THIS IS A SAVINGS OF $300,000.
6. WE CAN ALSO SELL SEVERAL EXTRA BUSES FOR A PROFIT TO BE DIVIDED BETWEEN THE DISTRICTS.
7. WE CAN SET UP A THREE TIER PROGRAM: ALL THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS ARRIVE AT 8:45 A.M. , MIDDLE SCHOOL AND BTES ARRIVE AT 8:05 A.M., AND THEN THE HIGH SCHOOL ARRIVES AT 7:05 A.M.
8. STATE REPORTING WOULD BE MORE EFFICIENT.
9. MERGING WOULD PROVIDE MORE SUB DRIVERS AND MORE FLEXIBILITY FOR TRANSPORTATION.
10. WE WOULD ALSO SAVE ON BUS PARTS AS WE CAN STRIP OLDER BUSES FOR USED PARTS/.
Eagleguy
9:51 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Pellecchia needs to go so that the boards can work together.
dorothy meelheim
10:15 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Berkeley currently operates with 21 drivers, 21 routes for all students. The other busses ar
e spares.
Black Sheep
4:12 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
The two districts, along with the town council need to put their heads together and where it is possible consolidate some departments-they have an obligation to the taxpayers. The next area that needs to be consolidated are police forces. Ocean Gate, Pine Beach and Beachwood should be one force. This would eliminate 2 chiefs and many sergeants and captains all making well over 100K.
dorothy meelheim
4:12 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Berkeley Township may have 32 total busses and vans, however currently there are 21 run packages, and 21 contracted drivers transporting all of the berkeley students, the other busses and vans are spares. New busses are not necessarily purchased each year, only when they "age out" by regulations. Central Regional occasionally will use Berkeley spare busses/vans and also spare busses are used by Berkeley Recreation. The bus maintenance/garage/mechanic services are shared . Lacey Twp. also has a much higher percentage of "walker" students as there are sidewalks and crossing guards to allow a larger number of students to be non-bussed.
dorothy meelheim
10:15 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
This is fact, I work for berkeley as a bus driver. We are doing a great job and Central Regional is doing a great job as well transporting our students. There is no real money to be saved in this area, It has been calculated to be approximately $3. per household tax revenue. Look me up on DATA Universe, after 22 years I make under 27k per year. Most drivers have been here less time, making less annual salary. This seems to be a political game. I am tired of keeping my mouth shut because I shouldn't voice an opinion regading my public job. We love our jobs, we love the kids, we do our absolute best. You will not save money cutting from the bottom.
voice of reason
1:07 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Fact is for a district with 4300 students they dont need 70 school buses also no one said drivers dont do a good job. If you read the proposal no one is saying drivers will loose there jobs ( or cut from the bottom as you indicate ) In reference to walkers all you have to do is drive by any of Berkeley ElementrySchools and you will see alot of parents dropping of there kids and also kids walking.If Bekeley has 32 buses with11 of them being spares why did they buy 2 new buses this year ? From what i am reading i think the taxpayers are being very generous in allowing drivers to retire and then not replacing them instead of letting them all go. If you think this merge is not going to save taxpayers money you been working 22 years to long collecting taxpayers $$$$$$$$$$
Dawn Parks
4:47 pm on Sunday, February 3, 2013
Mrs. MeelHeim,
I’m answering your last comment on this article. I never mention in my proposal that any bus drivers were not doing there jobs. I feel that every single one of our bus drivers in both district are doing a wonderful and great job with our kids. You should know that considering you drove both my kids to school at one time.
As for your comment on this seems to be a political game. I think you know that I’m know longer sitting on Berkeley Township Board of ed. because of the exact comment you said. I don’t need any political game for me. What I do need is things to be done right for the taxpayers of this town. Considering that our own town council president and Mayor made a comment in the Berkeley Patch about a week and ½ ago that this town is in dire straights and that our taxes will be going up again.
The only way that we can look at saving money would be through shared services with the bus fleet through both our school districts. Considering most of our taxes come from our school taxes.
I understand that you are employed by the Berkeley School district, but being a long time well know resident and a taxpayer. I would hope that you would consider looking at all options.
Dawn Parks
dorothy meelheim
10:11 am on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Thank you Dawn for your comment, however rather than posting on Patch you could have spoken to me directly and privately at the town council meeting Monday.....rather than just saying hello and ignoring me.... once again using this joke of a public forum for whatever your personal adjenda may be.
Dawn Parks
3:21 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Dorothy, the gate swing’s both ways. I would hope that you know that my door is always open if you needed to speak to me. If you saw when I placed this post, it was way before the council meeting, actually 10 days ago.
If you needed to speak to me at the council meeting, all you needed to do was ask me if you could have a minute. As you know it was very crowed when I arrived and if you heard my husband saying are you coming .
There was no ignoring anyone. Just please ask next time.
By the way, I wasn’t even there for the bus issue on Monday night. I signed in to speak about debri and construction from Hurricane Sandy.
As I stated there is no agenda. Just things to get done the right way and to start saving the taxpayers money.
dorothy meelheim
8:38 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Hello Dawn, You have once again challenged me on this public forum so I feel the need to reply. I have no idea why you were at the Berkeley township Committee meeting on Monday because you left early. You posted your public comment to me on Sunday night and I didn't see it until today when I made a public reply to you. Apparantly YOU had an issue to discuss with ME, so why would I go to your door? I live practically across the street from you and you have my phone number. I do commend you for using your name as many who post here are cowards who hide behind screen names. If I have a personal issue with someone I will always address it privately and on a personal level. iI don't need to use a public forum to make a point PUBLICLY. You are correct in the fact that I am a long time and well known resident of Berkeley township. As a matter of fact I am in a five generation family spicifically in the Holly Park My pride and love for this town goes way beyond my job as a school bus driver for Berkeley Twp Schools, something you may never understand. continued
dorothy meelheim
8:38 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
My father the late Richard "Dick" H. Dickhaus sat on every board, committee and office here in Berkeley Township with the exception of scool and Mayor. A lifetime of dedication of my father and our family was instrumental to what Berkeley Township has become today.
Dorothy Dickhaus - Meelheim
Bill Suskevich
1:58 am on Friday, February 15, 2013
Bill Suskevich
If Fulcomer and Siddons have proposed ideas for reducing expenses and maintaining or reducing the tax burden on the citizens of Berkeley the plan should be looked at and judged upon it's merits. Merging services has been proven to reduce costs with no loss of service in many towns. The "deals" were to heve ended with Verano. A new beginning of honesty was presented and elected. That is what we expect. A room full of bus drivers was arranged by someone, they just didn't happen to be passing by. Lets all get real and honest. Thank you, Fulcomer & Siddons.
Southbound
11:05 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013
ENOUGH, DOROTHY AND DAWN. LET IT GO GUYS...........
As for DD; he was a shady guy and everybody knew it.
I think all bus driver positions should be eliminated and let the kids walk to school. Save alot of $$$$$ there........
dorothy meelheim
6:21 pm on Friday, March 8, 2013
I did let it go on Feb. 13...And who might you be? If you have something negative to say about someone publicly, be man enough to use your real name and don't cower behind a screen name.
Southbond
9:35 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013
You really don't want me to go down that road so back off ! ! !
dorothy meelheim
10:52 am on Monday, March 11, 2013
That's what i thought, sorry if you were offended